Gregor and the Marks of Secret: Writing War (Part 2)

d1e05d3d80af7d6193f0ed7c940550caGregor and the Marks of Secret is the fourth of the Underland Chronicles by Suzanne Collins.

In Gregor the Overlander I talked about how focused and subtle it was in its war themes. By the fourth book in the series, the message is much blunter, with Gregor outright questioning the place and necessity for war. Although this approach probably wouldn’t have worked in the earlier books, by now the series has built up to a point where it can support a harder look at the issue. (Spoilers ahead)

Gregor the Overlander shows how war can tear apart families and the fear that comes along with that. Gregor and the Prophecy of Bane is about the innocent children that can become targets. Gregor and the Curse of the Warmbloods depicts biological warfare. This one explores the beginnings of war.

I really like the reintroduction to the Bane in this book. He’s such a mess, perfect for Twirltongue’s manipulation. And Twirltongue. I hate her. Hate hate hate her! She’s so evil, inciting the humans to war.

Thalia’s death breaks my heart. Although she was only introduced in this book, she was so cute and innocent, and Hazard cared so much for her, that her death hits home. Both that and the nibblers’ (horrifying) genocide really brings up the intensity of this book.


Who gave you the right?? Fabulous fan art by Circe, alfredtalia.tumblr

The transition in both theme and intensity works. Have you ever read a book that seems like it’s going to deal with a big issue, a real moral dilemma, but then it side-steps it at the last moment? I know I have. And it’s frustrating, because the book could have meant something, but it decided to ‘play it safe.’ That doesn’t happen in Underland Chronicles.

Instead, the series builds up from a subtle message to a clear question. And as long as it’s done well (and doesn’t resort to ‘preaching’), that’s great. Series should grow and develop in their themes, as well as in their characters and plots. How boring would it be if the stakes never got higher after the first book? Or if any character development ended then? The theme development should be no different.

What are some other books with strong themes?


5 thoughts on “Gregor and the Marks of Secret: Writing War (Part 2)

  1. You’re one of the only people I’ve ‘met’ online who’s read these books. Underland fans are definitely in the minority (especially compared to the blockbuster success of the Hunger Games – which I also love).

    (Btw, I don’t want to seem like a creepy stalker or anything, reading and commenting on all these old blog posts. I just wanted to share my thoughts and all.)

    Thalia’s death hit me just as hard as Ares’ did, I think. Or at least almost as hard. 😦 And I hate Twitchtip, too!


    • Yay, a fellow Underland fan!! I had hoped with the success of Hunger Games the Underland fanbase would take off a bit, but no such luck.

      Thalia’s death was so sad! Although I definitely care more about Ares, hers was worse in some ways because of how innocent she was. Ares knew what he was getting into, but she had no idea. 😦

      ( 😀 Don’t worry about seeming stalkerish. I used to worry about commenting on old posts too, but now that I started a blog I like it! I see it as a compliment)


      • Argh. I meant Twirltongue, not Twitchtip. I hate Twirltongue. 😛

        I think I reacted more emotionally to everyone’s reaction to Thalia’s death, more than the death itself (since we didn’t get to know her all *that* well). Especially Hazard, of course. *sniffs*

        Man, I want to re-read the series now! 🙂


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s